Virtual Interview vs. Physical Interview: Which is the Better Choice?

What is a Virtual Interview?

A virtual interview is a job interview conducted remotely using video conferencing technology or other online communication platforms. In a virtual interview, both the interviewer and the candidate participate from separate locations, typically using their computers or mobile devices to connect.

This approach has gained popularity due to factors such as remote work arrangements, travel restrictions, and health concerns, particularly amidst events like the COVID-19 pandemic. It offers the convenience of interviewing from the comfort of one's home or office, eliminating the need for travel and reducing the risk of exposure to infectious diseases.

What is a Physical Interview?

A physical interview is a traditional face-to-face interview conducted in person, where the interviewer and the candidate meet at a specific location, such as the company's office or a designated interview venue. Physical interviews allow for direct, in-person interaction between the interviewer and the candidate.

This approach allows for more direct observation of non-verbal cues and a potentially more immersive experience for both the interviewer and the candidate.

Pros and Cons of Virtual Interviews

Advantages of Virtual Interviews

• Efficiency: Online interviews tend to be shorter and require less downtime between sessions, enabling the possibility of interviewing more candidates in a single day and streamlining the hiring process.
• Flexibility: By eliminating the need for travel and logistical arrangements, candidates are more readily available for interviews. This flexibility extends to the interviewing team, who can participate from their workstations or home environments.
• Expanded Candidate Pool: Virtual interviews remove geographical barriers, allowing candidates from out-of-town locations to participate without the need for travel. Emphasizing your willingness to conduct online interviews can attract a broader range of high-quality applicants.
• Enhanced Internal Collaboration: Virtual interviews enable team members from different locations to participate, providing valuable feedback on potential candidates and fostering a collaborative hiring process.

Disadvantages of Virtual Interviews

• Technical Challenges: Online interviews are susceptible to network issues and software glitches, potentially disrupting or complicating the interview process and placing affected candidates at a disadvantage.
• Accessibility Concerns: Some candidates may lack access to the necessary technology, hindering their ability to participate fully in online interviews.
• Distractions: Both the interviewing team and candidates may face distractions in their surroundings, potentially affecting focus and engagement during the interview. Multiple team members participating in the interview may also increase the likelihood of interruptions due to other work-related tasks.

Pros and Cons of Physical Interviews

Advantages of Physical Interviews

• Observation of Body Language: In-person interviews provide an opportunity to observe candidates' non-verbal cues, which can convey valuable information not always captured on screen. Being face-to-face makes it easier to interpret body language, complementing verbal communication.
• Assessment of Interpersonal Skills: Being in the same physical space as candidates allows for a deeper understanding of their interpersonal abilities. While nervousness during interviews may influence behavior, face-to-face interactions offer insights into how candidates handle real-life interpersonal scenarios, essential for various job roles.
• Utilization of Visual Aids: In-person interviews facilitate the use of visual aids to showcase the company and its offerings, helping to engage candidates and communicate the organization's values effectively.
• Rapport Building: Some individuals struggle to establish rapport virtually. In-person interviews provide an opportunity for the hiring team to establish meaningful connections with candidates, fostering a more personal and engaging interaction that may not be achievable remotely.

Disadvantages of Physical Interviews

• Risk of Bias: In-person interviews may inadvertently disadvantage certain individuals, such as those with disabilities or from underrepresented groups. Additionally, scheduling constraints may exclude candidates who face challenges with travel arrangements, impacting diversity and inclusivity.
• Potential for Delays: While not susceptible to technical glitches, unforeseen circumstances like traffic accidents or flight delays can disrupt the interview schedule, causing candidates to arrive late or cancel at short notice.
• Increased Pressure: Face-to-face interviews can be more stressful for candidates, potentially affecting their performance and inhibiting introverted candidates from showcasing their full potential under pressure.
  

Which Interview Approach is Suitable for Your Business?

When deciding on the appropriate interview method for an open position, consider the following factors:

1. Stage of the Hiring Process:

• Virtual interviews may streamline early rounds, facilitating a smoother initial assessment of candidates. However, as you narrow down the candidate pool, inviting finalists for in-person interviews provides an opportunity for them to experience your workplace environment and allows for a deeper evaluation.

2. Turnover Rate of the Position:

• For roles with high turnover, virtual interviews offer a cost-effective and efficient option to expedite hiring processes. Conversely, for positions expected to remain filled for an extended period, in-person interviews may be preferable for thorough candidate evaluation.

3. Nature of Job Duties:

• Virtual interviews are beneficial for positions involving telework or frequent virtual interactions, enabling assessment of candidates' remote communication skills. In contrast, roles requiring daily face-to-face interactions may warrant in-person interviews to gauge interpersonal capabilities effectively.

4. Recruitment Scope:

• Conducting a nationwide job search may make virtual interviews more convenient for both your company and candidates, eliminating geographical barriers. Conversely, if your recruitment efforts are localized, in-person interviews may be more practical and preferred.

5. Availability of Software:

• If your company lacks adequate video interviewing software or has recently acquired it, consider postponing virtual interviews until your team is proficient with the technology. Ensuring software readiness enhances the effectiveness of virtual interviews.

6. Candidate Preference:

• Offer candidates the option to choose between in-person and virtual interviews, allowing them to select the format in which they feel most comfortable. Many candidates appreciate the authenticity and convenience of virtual interviews, which can alleviate stress and facilitate a genuine connection during the interview process.

Choosing between virtual and physical interviews depends on factors like job requirements, candidate preferences, and current circumstances. Both approaches offer distinct advantages, with virtual interviews providing flexibility and convenience, while physical interviews offer direct interaction and immersion. By carefully considering these factors, businesses can select the interview approach that best suits their needs and goals, ensuring successful hiring outcomes.

AJOBTHING: Your All-in-One Hiring Solution

With AJOBTHING, you get everything you need for hiring in one place. Our HR libraries are packed with helpful resources, and our recruiter advice is personalized to your hiring needs. No more juggling multiple platforms. With AJOBTHING, everything you need is in one convenient place. Join us today and see how we can make hiring simpler and more effective for you.

Urgently seeking candidates to hire?
Look no further! AJobThing offers an effective hiring solution with our instant job ad feature. Hire in just 72 hours! Try Now!

Read More on AJobThing:

• Recruiting the Future Talent: Generation Z (Gen Z)
• Tips for Interviewer: Job Interview Dos and Don'ts
• Reasons to Hire Working Moms (and How to Hire and Retain)
• HR Practice: New Employee Onboarding Process and Checklist
• Finding the Perfect Fit: 5 Personality Tests for Hiring Process