How HR and Employers Should Handle Salary Expectations in Interviews

For most candidates, salary is one of the biggest deciding factors when choosing a job. Even if the role and culture look great, an offer that feels “off” can make them walk away. That’s why employers need a structured way to ask and discuss salary expectations, not just last-minute negotiations at the end of the process.

When salary conversations are planned properly, you avoid mismatched expectations, endless back-and-forth, and candidates dropping off after several interview rounds.

In Malaysia’s current job market, where competition, inflation, and talent shortages are real, job seekers increasingly expect transparent, respectful discussions about pay, benefits, and growth before they say “yes”.

What are Salary Expectations?

Salary expectations are the monthly or annual pay range a candidate expects when applying or interviewing for a job. They are usually based on:

Industry salary benchmarks
The candidate’s years of experience and skills
The value and seniority of the role
Their current or previous salary and personal financial situation

Salary expectations are a starting point for alignment. The real question is, “Do this candidate’s expectations fit our salary structure and budget for this role?” If not, HR needs a clear way to respond, not just a silent rejection.

Why Salary Discussions Matter for Employers

Salary conversations help employers:

Prevent Surprises Later

If expectations are far above your range, it’s better to know in the screening stage than after 3–4 interviews.

Reduce Negotiation Friction

Clear, calm pay discussions reduce tense “last-minute” negotiations and emotional conversations at the offer stage.

Align Budget with Reality

When you know what the market expects, you can adjust your budget or role level more strategically.

Improve Employer Branding

Transparent, respectful pay discussions make candidates feel your company is professional and fair. That improves how they talk about you, even if you don’t hire them.

What Employers Should Consider Before Asking Salary Expectations

Before you ask any candidate, HR and hiring managers should align on:

Budget Allocation for the Role

What is your approved salary range? Is there flexibility if you meet an exceptional candidate?

Internal Salary Fairness

Are you paying similar roles roughly in the same band? Offering much higher pay to a new joiner than an existing staff in the same level can cause internal tension and future retention issues.

Market Salary Range in Malaysia

Look at salary surveys, job ads, and competitor offers for similar roles. If your range is far below market, expect more rejections or low-quality applicants.

Job Grade and Total Rewards

Confirm the grade level and what comes with it, such as:

Fixed allowances (transport, mobile, meal)
Commission or incentive schemes
Bonus opportunities
Leave, insurance, and other benefits

Inflation and Cost of Living

Many Malaysian workers are thinking about rental, fuel, childcare, and food prices. Salary expectations may reflect real financial pressure, not “overconfidence”.

Once these points are clear, HR can ask about salary expectations with more confidence and honesty.

How Employers Should Ask About Salary Expectations

You can use phrases like:

“To make sure we are aligned, what is your expected salary range for this role?”
“May I know your expected total monthly compensation, including basic salary and any allowances or incentives you typically receive?”
“Based on your experience and the responsibilities of this role, what range would you be comfortable with?”

Tips when asking:

Give context first (role, level, responsibilities, work arrangement).
Encourage candidates to share a range, not a fixed number.
Let them know salary is one part of the total package which also includes benefits, bonuses, and other perks.

How to Evaluate Salary Expectations Fairly

When a candidate shares their expectations, HR should compare it against:

Company Salary Band for the Role

Is the range inside, slightly above, or far above your band?

Skills, Certifications, and Proven Outcomes

Does the candidate bring extra value (e.g. rare skills, industry contacts, leadership experience) that justifies the higher range?

Industry Salary Benchmark

Are they asking something normal for the market, or far higher than what similar roles get?

Internal Equity

How does this figure sit compared to current team members in similar positions? If you go higher, do you have a plan to avoid future pay complaints?

If expectations are above your band, you don’t have to reject immediately. You can:

Share your range honestly
Explain how it was set (grade, market, internal fairness)
Ask if the candidate is open to consider it

This feels more respectful than just saying “too expensive”.

How Employers Should Respond to High Salary Expectations

Step 1: Clarify flexibility

You can ask:

“Thanks for sharing your expectation of RMX–RMY. Our current band for this role is around RM[A]–RM[B]. May I know if your range is flexible within this band?”

Sometimes candidates will built in negotiation room or open to lower base if other parts of the package are strong.

Step 2: Offer non-salary levers (if suitable)

If you cannot fully meet the number but still value the candidate, you can discuss:

Hybrid/Flexible Work

“We may not be able to meet the top of your salary range, but this role does offer hybrid work with X days from home, which some candidates value highly.”

Training and Development

“We invest in certifications and learning that can increase your future earning potential.”

Performance Bonuses

“Your basic salary would be RMX, with performance bonuses of up to Y% based on results.”

Probation or Milestone Review

“We could start at RMX, with a review after 6 months. If performance meets agreed milestones, we can discuss an adjustment.”

What Malaysian Employers Commonly Overlook

Common blind spots:

Assuming Salary Expectations are Unreasonable

Often, expectations reflect real market demand and rising cost of living, especially in Klang Valley and major cities.

Focusing Only on Basic Salary

Candidates care about:

Benefits
Allowances
Work–life balance
Flexibility

If you don’t explain these clearly, your offer may look lower than competitors even if total value is similar.

Underpaying and Hoping Loyalty will Solve It

Underpaying good talent usually leads to:

Early resignation when a better offer appears
Low engagement and quiet job searching

Long term, the cost of replacing people repeatedly is higher than paying fairly.

How Malaysian Employers Should Frame Total Compensation

When you present offers or discuss expectations, frame total compensation, for example:

Basic Salary (monthly)
EPF Employer Contribution (e.g. 12% or higher, depending on policy)
SOCSO & EIS (statutory protections)
OT eligibility (who gets OT, how it’s calculated, weekend/public holiday rates if applicable)
Allowances:
- Mobile / phone allowance
- Transport / petrol allowance
- Meal allowance or food subsidy
- Parking subsidy or company-paid parking
Medical Coverage:
- Panel clinics and hospital coverage
- Family/dependant coverage (if any)
- Outpatient, dental, optical limits
Incentives and Bonuses:
- KPI or performance bonus formula
- Sales or commission scheme
- Annual bonus range or structure
Other Perks:
- Hybrid/remote work options
- Training and certification support
- Wellness or staff discount programmes

Avoid These Salary Conversation Mistakes

Common mistakes to avoid:

Asking Salary Expectations Too Late

If you only ask at the final stage, you risk losing candidates after a heavy time investment on both sides.

Unclear Salary Details

Saying “we’ll discuss later” again and again makes candidates anxious and more likely to continue interviewing elsewhere.

Basing Everything on Past Salary

Many markets are moving towards paying based on job value and skills, not just “add 10–15% to your last salary”. Past salary may have been under-market, especially for B40/M40 or those switching industries.

Offering Low Salary but Expecting Strong Interest

If your offer is significantly below market, candidates will either reject quickly or accept while still actively searching.

Inconsistent Practices

Asking detailed expectations from some candidates but not others may create fairness concerns and internal perception problems.

FAQs

What if a candidate refuses to reveal salary expectations?

Some candidates prefer not to share first. You can respond with:

“That’s okay, we understand. For transparency, our range for this role is around RMX–RMY, depending on experience. Does this fit what you are roughly looking for?”

This keeps the conversation moving without pushing too hard.

Should employers reveal their salary range first?

Whenever possible, yes. Sharing a range:

Builds trust and shows you’re not playing games
Helps candidates self-select
Saves time on both sides

You can still refine the final number based on experience and internal equity.

What if the candidate’s expectation exceeds the budget?

First, check if your budget is realistic compared to the market. If it is, you can:

Explain your range and how it was set
Ask if they are flexible
Offer non-salary elements (hybrid work, training, bonus, earlier review)

If there’s still no alignment, decline respectfully. Keeping the door open for future roles is better than forcing a bad deal.

How do Malaysian laws affect salary negotiation?

In Malaysia, salary discussions must still respect:

Minimum wage regulations
Employment Act rules on hours, OT, rest days, and public holidays for covered employees
Statutory contributions: EPF, SOCSO, EIS, PCB (tax)

While negotiation is allowed, employers cannot go below legal minimums or ignore statutory obligations. When in doubt, check with internal legal or official government guidelines.

Should salary be based on past salary or job value?

Best practice is to use job value and market rate as the main anchor, with past salary as a reference, not a rule.

Relying only on past salary can:

Lock in historical underpayment
Create internal inequity (especially if newer hires come from higher-paying companies)

A more sustainable approach is to define clear salary bands based on role, skills, and market, then place candidates fairly within those bands.

Looking for Qualified Candidates? We’re Here to Help!

With AJobThing, access a massive pool of jobseekers and hire the right talent faster than ever.

Get started today and fill your vacancies with ease!