Internal vs External Hiring: Pros, Cons, and When to Use

When it comes to filling a job opening, employers have two main routes: internal and external hiring.

Each method has its own set of benefits and challenges, making it important to understand which one best suits your needs.

Whether you’re promoting from within or bringing in fresh talent from outside, both processes can impact your company’s culture, growth, and performance.

In this article, we’ll compare internal versus external hiring by looking at how each process works, the pros and cons, and when it’s best to choose one over the other.

What is the Internal Hiring Process?

Internal hiring involves filling job vacancies with current employees from within the organization.

It can include promotions, lateral moves, or transferring employees to different departments.

This process helps retain top talent and motivates employees by offering career advancement opportunities.

Steps Involved

Identifying talent. Look at current employees who have the skills and potential for the open role.
Internal job postings. Advertise the job internally so employees can apply.
Evaluations. Assess employee performance, skills, and fit for the new role, often through performance reviews or skills assessments.

What is the External Hiring Process?

External hiring is when a company seeks candidates outside its organization to fill job openings.

It involves sourcing talent through job boards, recruitment agencies, campus recruitment, and other external channels.

Steps Involved

Sourcing candidates. Identify potential candidates through job boards, social media, or headhunters.
Screening. Review resumes, conduct background checks, and assess candidates’ qualifications.
Interviewing. Shortlisted candidates are invited for interviews to assess their skills, experience, and fit.
Onboarding. Once hired, candidates go through a process to integrate into the company, including training and orientation.

Internal vs. External Hiring: Key Differences

After understanding the definitions, let’s dive into the key differences between internal and external hiring. Below is a quick comparison to help you decide which process aligns better with your company’s goals.

Aspect	Internal Hiring	External Hiring
Talent pool	Limited to current employees, which can restrict options but ensures cultural fit.	Broader and more diverse, offering access to new perspectives and untapped skills.
Cost	Lower costs since sourcing and onboarding are simpler and quicker.	Higher costs for advertisements, recruiter fees, and extended onboarding processes.
Time-to-fill	Faster because candidates are already familiar with the company and its processes.	Slower due to longer steps like sourcing, screening, and background checks.
Innovation and skills	Build on existing skills but may limit innovation and creativity.	Brings in fresh ideas, specialized expertise, and external market knowledge.
Employee morale	Boosts engagement and retention by offering growth and development opportunities.	Can cause dissatisfaction among employees if internal talent feels overlooked.

From the table, you can see that internal hiring is faster and more cost effective, boosting employee morale but limiting diversity.

On the other hand, external hiring brings fresh ideas and a broader talent pool but takes more time and resources.

Advantages of the Internal vs External Hiring Process

Both internal and external hiring come with unique perks.

The best option depends on your goals, whether it’s saving time and costs or bringing fresh ideas to the team. Let’s break it down.

Internal Hiring Advantages

1. Lower costs

Internal hiring is more budget-friendly since there’s no need for advertising, recruiters, or extensive onboarding.

2. Faster onboarding

Existing employees are already familiar with company processes, making adaptation quicker.

3. Boosts morale

Promoting or moving employees internally shows you value their growth, which builds motivation and loyalty.

4. Retain knowledge

Employees already understand the company culture, goals, and systems, keeping institutional knowledge intact.

External Hiring Advantage

1. New ideas and skills

External candidates bring fresh perspectives and expertise that can invigorate your team.

2. Diverse talent pool

Hiring externally increases diversity, which often leads to more innovative solutions.

3. Specialized expertise

External hiring is ideal for filling roles that require niche skills or experience unavailable within the company.

Drawbacks of the Internal vs External Hiring Process

While both internal and external hiring have their benefits, they also come with certain downsides. Here’s a closer look at the challenges of each approach.

Internal Hiring Drawbacks

1. Limited diversity

Sticking to internal candidates can limit fresh ideas and diverse perspectives.

2. Internal politics

Favoritism or perceived bias can create tension and affect workplace harmony.

3. Knowledge gaps

Promoting employees may leave behind critical gaps in their previous roles.

External Hiring Drawbacks

1. Higher costs

External recruitment often involves expenses for job ads, recruiters, and onboarding.

2. Longer time-to-fill

Finding, vetting, and hiring external candidates takes more time.

3. Cultural misalignment

External hires may struggle to adapt to your company culture, leading to a higher risk of turnover.

When to Choose Internal vs External Hiring

Choosing between internal and external hiring depends on your company’s needs and goals. Here’s a simple guide to help you decide.

Internal Hiring: When to Use

Leadership roles

Promoting from within works well for positions that require a deep understanding of the company culture and operations.

Retain knowledge

When it’s important to keep institutional knowledge within the company, internal hiring is the way to go.

Employee motivation

Internal hiring can boost morale and show employees that growth opportunities are available, which can increase loyalty and retention.

External Hiring: When to Use

Innovation

If your team needs fresh ideas or creative solutions, hiring externally is ideal to bring in new perspectives.

Skill gaps

When there’s a lack of specific expertise or technical skills internally, external candidates can fill those gaps.

Expansion

If you're entering new markets or need specialized experience, external hires can provide the knowledge and experience needed for growth.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How to balance internal promotions with external hiring needs?

Start by assessing the role and what’s needed. Internal promotions work for retaining knowledge and motivating employees, while external hires bring fresh skills. A mix of both ensures you meet immediate needs and long-term goals.

What tools can help manage internal and external hiring processes?

Use Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) like Workday, BambooHR, or Maukerja to streamline external hiring. For internal hiring, tools like Slack or intranet portals can help share job openings and track applications.

How to maintain employee satisfaction when prioritizing external hiring?

Communicate openly about why external hiring is necessary and how it benefits the company. Offer clear growth paths for existing employees to keep them motivated.

Are there legal considerations for internal hiring in Malaysia?

Yes, ensure promotions and transfer comply with the employment contracts and anti-discrimination laws in Malaysia. Always document decisions to avoid any legal issues.

How A Job Thing Can Help

Try AJobThing's instant job ad now! Get your open positions seen by qualified candidates quickly and easily.