Reference Checks: A Complete Guide for Recruiters

Hiring someone is like buying a car. The resume is the glossy brochure, and the interview is your test drive. But how do you know the engine is reliable? This is the role of a reference check.

It gives you the inside scoop from those who’ve worked with the candidate before, helping you avoid surprises down the road.

For employers in Malaysia, a well-done reference check isn’t just a formality. It’s a smart move to ensure you’re investing in the right person.

Let’s dive into what makes a reference check effective and how to get started.

What Are Reference Checks?

A reference check is when you contact people who’ve worked with a job candidate before, such as their former managers, colleagues, or clients.

The purpose is simple: to get a clearer picture of the candidate’s performance, behavior, and skills from someone who knows them well.

This step usually happens after the interview and before you make a job offer.

It’s like a final checkpoint to confirm what the candidate has told you.

Reference checks can help validate their strengths, address any doubts, and give you the confidence to move forward—or decide they might not be the right fit.

It’s a small step that can save you from costly hiring mistakes.

Why Are Reference Checks Important?

Reference checks are a key step in hiring that many employers overlook. Here’s why they matter:

1. Confirm Skills and Past Performance

Resumes and interviews can look great, but how do you know if they’re accurate?

Reference checks let you verify a candidate’s skills, work ethic, and achievements by hearing from people who’ve worked with them before.

This helps you separate facts from exaggerations.

2. Ensure They Fit Your Team

A good hire isn’t just about qualifications, it’s about finding someone who works well with your team and fits your company culture.

Reference checks reveal how candidates handle challenges, collaborate with others, and adapt to different environments.

This insight helps you decide if they’re the right fit.

3. Reduce Hiring Risks

Hiring the wrong person can be expensive and stressful for your team.

Reference checks act as a safeguard by uncovering any red flags, like poor performance or unprofessional behavior.

They help you make smarter decisions and avoid costly mistakes.

Types of information gathered in reference checks

Reference checks offer a chance to dig deeper into a candidate’s past, beyond what’s written on paper.

Here’s the kind of information you can gather to make a better-informed decision:

1. Employment history

You can confirm key details like job titles, responsibilities, and the dates a candidate was employed.

This ensures their resume matches their actual work history and gives you a clearer picture of their career path.

2. Performance

Reference checks give you insights into the candidate’s strengths, areas for improvement, and key achievements.

It’s a way to see how they’ve contributed in past roles and whether they consistently performed at a high level.

3. Interpersonal skills

You’ll get feedback on how the candidate worked with others, including their teamwork, leadership, and communication skills.

This helps you gauge how well they’ll fit into your company’s culture.

4. Work ethic

References can provide insight into a candidate’s reliability, punctuality, and overall integrity.

This helps you determine if they can be trusted to meet deadlines and show up consistently for the job.

How to conduct a reference check

Here’s a simple guide to conducting a reference check:

1. Get Permission

Always ask the candidate for permission before contacting their references.

This is respectful and required by Malaysia’s Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA). Make sure they provide accurate contact details.

2. Choose the Right People

Contact referees who have worked closely with the candidate, like former managers or teammates.

These people can give you useful insights into the candidate’s work performance.

3. Prepare Your Questions

Plan your questions in advance. Focus on work-related topics like:

The candidate’s strengths.
How they work with others.
Challenges they’ve handled.

Avoid personal or unrelated topics like age or family.

4. Be Professional

When reaching out, introduce yourself and explain why you’re calling. Be polite, keep the conversation confidential, and schedule the call at a time that suits them.

5. Take Notes

Write down what the referee says, including specific examples. These notes will help you compare candidates and make informed decisions.

Sample questions for reference checks

Here are some essential questions to ask during a reference check, along with a brief explanation of why each one is important:

1. Can you confirm the candidate’s job title and responsibilities?

This helps verify the candidate’s work history and ensures their resume matches their actual duties. It confirms if they have the experience they claim.

2. What were their main strengths and contributions?

This question reveals the candidate’s key strengths and positive impact. It shows what they excelled at and how they added value to the team.

3. How did they handle challenges or conflict?

Understanding how the candidate deals with challenges or conflict highlights their problem-solving skills, emotional intelligence, and ability to handle pressure or disagreements.

4. Would you hire this person again? Why or why not?

This is a clear indicator of the candidate’s overall performance. A “yes” response with reasons builds confidence, while a “no” could signal a red flag worth exploring.

5. How well did they work within a team?

Teamwork is crucial in most roles. This question assesses the candidate’s ability to collaborate, communicate, and contribute to group success.

6. Were there any areas where the candidate could improve?

This provides honest insight into the candidate’s weaknesses and areas for growth, helping you assess if they are open to development.

Challenges in conducting reference checks

There are several challenges employers may face during the reference check process. Here are some common obstacles and how to navigate them:

1. Unclear or Overly Positive Feedback

Referees may give vague or overly positive feedback, making it hard to assess the candidate.

To avoid this, ask specific questions like, “Can you share an example of how the candidate worked in a team?” This helps get clearer insights into their skills.

2. Difficult-to-Contact Referees

Reaching past employers can be tough if the company closed or the referee is unavailable.

Try contacting the HR department or finding other colleagues from the same company for feedback.

3. Privacy and Legal Issues

Follow privacy laws like Malaysia’s PDPA when checking references. Always get the candidate’s consent and focus only on job-related questions to stay compliant.

Best practices for reference checks in Malaysia

To ensure your checks are effective and reliable, here are some best practices to follow:

1. Verify Referee Details

Always confirm referees’ contact details to ensure they are valid.

A quick LinkedIn check or visiting the company website can confirm the referee’s credibility and connection to the candidate.

2. Speak to Multiple Referees

Relying on one referee can give a narrow view. Talking to multiple referees provides a well-rounded perspective on the candidate’s skills, behavior, and work performance.

3. Use Feedback in Your Evaluation

Reference checks are not just formalities.

Use the insights to compare with the candidate’s resume, interview, and other assessments for a clearer hiring decision.

4. Maintain Consistency

Ask all candidates the same questions during reference checks to ensure fairness.

This approach makes it easier to compare and evaluate candidates objectively.

5. Respect Privacy

Handle reference check information with care. Keep details confidential and use them solely for the hiring process to maintain trust with both the candidate and referees.

Legal and ethical considerations

When conducting reference checks in Malaysia, it’s essential to comply with labor laws and the PDPA. This means obtaining the candidate’s consent before contacting any referees.

Also, ensuring that you only collect job-related information. Any personal or sensitive data should be handled carefully and in compliance with privacy regulations.

Additionally, maintaining confidentiality is crucial. Keep all reference check information private and use it only for the hiring process.

This respects both the candidate’s and the referee’s privacy, fostering trust and ensuring a fair, ethical hiring process.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How many references should be checked?

Typically, checking 2-3 references is recommended to get a well-rounded view of a candidate. However, depending on the role, you may need to check more to ensure you’re gathering enough insight.

Can reference checks reveal salary information?

In most cases, reference checks focus on performance and behavior rather than salary details. It’s uncommon to obtain salary information unless the referee directly discloses it.

What should employers do if referees are unresponsive?

If a referee is unresponsive, try reaching out through a different communication channel or offer to conduct the check at a more convenient time. If that doesn’t work, consider contacting another referee from the same company or team.

Find the Perfect Fit Fast!

Combine reference checks with AJobThing’s tools to find top talent quickly and efficiently.